Skip To Main Content

Susquehanna University Athletics

Official Athletics Site of

Scoreboard Tab

Football Suffers Heartbreaking Loss to Gettysburg

Box Score

Box Score

GETTYSBURG, Pa. – A near impossible comeback found the Susquehanna football team on the wrong side of a 61-50 decision against Gettysburg on Saturday afternoon.

Susquehanna (1-8, 1-8) saw what had been a 23-point lead disappear following 34 unanswered Gettysburg points in the third and fourth quarters in one of the highest-scoring games in recent SU history.

The Crusader offense put up the most points it has in six years, but the defense could not contain the Centennial Conference's top-ranked offense in the Bullets (5-3, 4-3). The teams combined for 111 points and 1,162 yards of offense.

Junior quarterback Rich Palazzi (Newfoundland, Pa./Wallenpaupack) finished the afternoon with 286 passing yards and four touchdowns en route to 518 total offensive yards for the Crusaders.

Greg Tellish (Mount Airy, Md./South Carroll) led the SU running game, rushing for 142 yards and a touchdown on 23 carries. Four different receivers caught touchdown passes from Palazzi, with Mike Ritter (Selinsgrove, Pa./Selinsgrove Area) leading the way with two scores and 140 yards on seven receptions.

Palazzi worked SU down the field to open the game, aided in part by a 13-yard completion to Justin Stover (Selinsgrove, Pa./Selinsgrove Area). Two costly penalties against the Bullets, including a pass interference call on what would have been a touchdown reception from Palazzi to Ritter, prolonged SU's drive.

That call placed the Crusaders on the Gettysburg five-yard line. Palazzi opted for a quarterback sneak and pushed his way into the endzone. After Bobby Eppleman's (Chester Springs, Pa./Great Valley) PAT, it stood 7-0 after less than five minutes of action.

On their second offensive possession, the Bullets took over on Susquehanna's 45-yard line following an usually short Eppleman punt. The ensuing drive ended in a 12-yard Charles Curcio touchdown run to knot the game at seven-all, still with more than five minutes to play in the opening quarter.

It took Palazzi and SU less than two minutes to respond as the junior signal caller connected with his classmate, Ritter, on a perfectly-thrown pass and Ritter ran his way into the endzone for a 68-yard score. Eppleman missed the extra point, however, and it stood 13-7 with 3:27 on the clock.

The momentum remained squarely on Susquehanna's side when Mitch Phillips (Millersburg, Pa./Millersburg Area) promptly picked off QB Kyle Whitmoyer. Despite unsportsmanlike penalties against both teams following the kickoff, Palazzi remained unfazed and found Spencer Cox (Myersville, Md./Frederick/Brevard) for another SU touchdown.

Eppleman's struggles continued, though, as his extra point attempt was blocked and Susquehanna led 19-7 as the first quarter came to a close.

Despite working its way to the Susquehanna one-yard line, the SU defense stopped the Bullets on three-straight goal-line plays. On the third play, Teighler Doak (Selinsgrove, Pa./Selinsgrove Area/Robert Morris) had an interception go in and out of his hands and Gettysburg took advantage of that extra chance when Anthony DeSalva pushed his way into the endzone for a 19-14 game.

Tellish continued Susquehanna's offensive explosion with a 37-yard scoring run on the Crusaders' first possession in the second quarter, upping the lead to 26-14.

As was the theme all game, Gettysburg countered with a scoring drive of its own that resulted in a 32-yard touchdown pass from Whitmoyer to Brian Betley. Fortunately for Susquehanna, point after attempts also proved troublesome for the Bullets, as a missed kick kept it a 26-20 score.

The Crusaders overcame a 3rd-and-15 situation late in the second quarter to ultimately score its fifth touchdown of the afternoon on a 21-yard scoring run by Tellish that put SU ahead 33-20.

Phillips made sure Gettysburg's offense remained dormant for the remainder of the half with a critical sack on 4th-and-8 that fired up the Crusaders. They were fired up enough to find the Gettysburg endzone for their sixth touchdown of the half when Connor McGrath (Sparta, N.J./Pope John XXIII Regional/Assumption) reeled in an over-the-shoulder pass from Palazzi and ran his way into the endzone for a 40-20 ballgame.

The Bullets came out of the break and promptly put together a 10-play scoring drive that added seven points via a 40-yard touchdown strike from Whitmoyer to Betley. Mike Barrett's PAT made it a two-score game (40-26).

With 6:16 left in the third quarter, Eppleman was forced into action for his first field-goal attempt of the game. The senior nailed a 29-yard kick to tack three points on the board and make it 43-27.

Ritter and Palazzi teamed up for the second time on a 37-yard touchdown play which, followed by Eppleman's PAT, made it 50-27 with 3:10 on the clock.

To no one's surprise, the Bullets countered with a touchdown of their own 43 seconds later as the shootout continued with the third quarter winding down and SU leading 50-34.

That marked the start of the Bullets' 34-0 run. Gettysburg made it two-straight scoring possessions when DeSalva's four-yard scoring rush quickly cut the Crusaders' lead to 10 (50-40) with 9:58 still to play.

The SU defense took the field with 7:39 left in a critical series for both teams as the clock continued to wind down, but it was Gettysburg that answered the call. Kyle Davis eluded a would-be SU tackler and ran his way into the endzone for a 78-yard score that cut what had once been a 23-point Susquehanna lead to only three (50-47).

On third and five with 3:43 on the clock, Ritter could not hang on to Palazzi's pass and the Bullets took over with good field position on their own 48. Whitmoyer proceeded to toss a 23-yard strike to Matt Brophy on the SU three-yard line and Curcio scored on a five-yard run that handed Gettysburg its first lead of the game, 54-50, and left the Crusaders only 1:40 with which to work.

On third and four, Palazzi was sacked and fumbled the ball which was recovered by Gettysburg on the SU 23-yard line. The Bullets added an insurance touchdown with 43 seconds on the clock to clinch the comeback with a 61-50 win.  

Next game: Saturday, Nov. 6 at WPI, 12 p.m. – season finale

Postgame Notes:

- Matt Lottes and Jack McCarty served as honorary captains

- The 111 combined points were the most scored in a Susquehanna game since a 62-61 double-overtime win against Juniata in 1998.

- Bobby Eppleman remained perfect on field goal attempts (8-for-8) this season.

Print Friendly Version

Players Mentioned

Spencer Cox

#82 Spencer Cox

DB
6' 1"
Junior
Bobby Eppleman

#47 Bobby Eppleman

P/K
6' 2"
Junior
Mitch Phillips

#56 Mitch Phillips

LB
6' 1"
Sophomore
Teighler Doak

#15 Teighler Doak

DB
5' 9"
Sophomore
Matt Lottes

#11 Matt Lottes

QB
6' 3"
Junior
Jack McCarty

#2 Jack McCarty

FS
5' 10"
Sophomore
Connor McGrath

#23 Connor McGrath

FB
5' 10"
Sophomore
Rich Palazzi

#17 Rich Palazzi

QB
5' 10"
Junior
Mike Ritter

#19 Mike Ritter

SE
5' 10"
Junior
Justin Stover

#13 Justin Stover

LB
6' 0"
Junior
Greg Tellish

#43 Greg Tellish

RB
5' 8"
Junior

Players Mentioned

Spencer Cox

#82 Spencer Cox

6' 1"
Junior
DB
Bobby Eppleman

#47 Bobby Eppleman

6' 2"
Junior
P/K
Mitch Phillips

#56 Mitch Phillips

6' 1"
Sophomore
LB
Teighler Doak

#15 Teighler Doak

5' 9"
Sophomore
DB
Matt Lottes

#11 Matt Lottes

6' 3"
Junior
QB
Jack McCarty

#2 Jack McCarty

5' 10"
Sophomore
FS
Connor McGrath

#23 Connor McGrath

5' 10"
Sophomore
FB
Rich Palazzi

#17 Rich Palazzi

5' 10"
Junior
QB
Mike Ritter

#19 Mike Ritter

5' 10"
Junior
SE
Justin Stover

#13 Justin Stover

6' 0"
Junior
LB
Greg Tellish

#43 Greg Tellish

5' 8"
Junior
RB
Skip Ad Advertisement
Skip Sponsors